I say public school also - however, with the right parent and the right support system, homeschool can be great. With that being said, my opinion is that everyone should go to public highschool. Not so much for the learning, but for the overall package.
Public School! I think kids need that social life that comes from public school. They also need different adults teaching them other than their parents so they learn respect for adults. Can you tell Im a huge advocate for public school. Plus if I ever did home school for my kids they wouldn't be very smart.
Public School. I was an ElEd major in college and I believe children benefit more from Public School. The social skills they gain are better at public school.
Totally Public School. Before Byron went into Public school I seriously thought about home schooling my kids, but now I see there are so many things he has gotten from Public school I would never keep him home. I think it is good for them to have to sit there in a classroom setting and learn from someone other than his mother. He learns social skills that teach him how to deal with people for the rest of his life. He learns that not everything in life is honkey dorry. He learns that there are consequences for his actions, not just ones his parents have taught him. I could write a book on this. But I'll stop before I get carried away.
I hate this debate. But I'll give you my opinion. Public school. I worked for the school district for 2 years and I have family that still does. But I think parent involment is the key.
charter school. I love the learning environment my boys are getting right now. public schools don't always have the teacher-student ratio that allows them to work with all the kids. my boys had some great teachers at Rock Canyon, but they could have benefited from something a little more flexible than public school. I agree they need the social skills of a school environment, but the public schools can be over crowded.
I don't have kids, and I only have experience with public school personally, but I do know a few people who were home schooled. I think in talking and interacting with one girl in particular I would not do home school because of the social learning that does not take place if a child is home schooled. I agree that parental involvement in public school is the key. Not a helicopter parenting style, but just being involved.
I think that you know your child better than anyone else on earth, and Heavenly Father knows them better that you. Pray about it. Some kids will do way better at home, others at school. I have my opinion for my own kids. You will find a way to meet all of their educational and social needs either way. They both take lots of effort on your part. I've looked into both, my mom has been on the School Board in WA for almost 16 years, my older sister has the home school debate with herself almost daily. I say weigh the pros and cons without emotion attached, pick what you think is best for your kids, pray for help, then give your all to your decision. You can always try home school and switch back to public school if it doesn't work out or if it becomes a better choice later. Don't rely on everyone else's opinion. You are totally capable of making that huge decision, without the guilt of what everyone else thinks (however well-intentioned, they are people who love you after all...), and you will make the right one. Melanie
I've been a public school teacher and I'm married to a public school teacher, so you know where I stand. Being involved, regular communication with the teacher and supplementing at home when needed - will cut any frustration down quite a bit. The social experience both good & bad is so important.
I would have said public until I married my husband who was home schooled. I still don't know what I will do with my own children, but I DO know that there are LOTS of benefits to homeschooling. And I think that children can get plenty of social interaction as long as parents make the effort to have them around other children - and it can definitely be outside of a public classroom. Let me also just say, that all home schooled children are NOT "weird," and there are PLENTY of "weird" kids that come out of a public school! There's lots more I could say, but I'll end by just saying that I think most people are too closed minded to the idea of home schooling because it takes a TON of effort from the parent. I think kids can benefit from either, and neither should be ruled out without serious contemplation.
13 comments:
Public School
I say public school also - however, with the right parent and the right support system, homeschool can be great. With that being said, my opinion is that everyone should go to public highschool. Not so much for the learning, but for the overall package.
Public School! I think kids need that social life that comes from public school. They also need different adults teaching them other than their parents so they learn respect for adults. Can you tell Im a huge advocate for public school. Plus if I ever did home school for my kids they wouldn't be very smart.
Public School. I was an ElEd major in college and I believe children benefit more from Public School. The social skills they gain are better at public school.
Totally Public School. Before Byron went into Public school I seriously thought about home schooling my kids, but now I see there are so many things he has gotten from Public school I would never keep him home. I think it is good for them to have to sit there in a classroom setting and learn from someone other than his mother. He learns social skills that teach him how to deal with people for the rest of his life. He learns that not everything in life is honkey dorry. He learns that there are consequences for his actions, not just ones his parents have taught him. I could write a book on this. But I'll stop before I get carried away.
I hate this debate. But I'll give you my opinion. Public school. I worked for the school district for 2 years and I have family that still does. But I think parent involment is the key.
charter school. I love the learning environment my boys are getting right now. public schools don't always have the teacher-student ratio that allows them to work with all the kids. my boys had some great teachers at Rock Canyon, but they could have benefited from something a little more flexible than public school. I agree they need the social skills of a school environment, but the public schools can be over crowded.
Yikes to both! :) I'd really do home school if I had the patience, but I don't, so I'm thinking private school may be worth the price.
I don't have kids, and I only have experience with public school personally, but I do know a few people who were home schooled. I think in talking and interacting with one girl in particular I would not do home school because of the social learning that does not take place if a child is home schooled. I agree that parental involvement in public school is the key. Not a helicopter parenting style, but just being involved.
Amen to all the comments- Every home schooled person i've met is- sorry to say- weird. You can spot them a mile away. Public all the way.
I think that you know your child better than anyone else on earth, and Heavenly Father knows them better that you. Pray about it. Some kids will do way better at home, others at school. I have my opinion for my own kids. You will find a way to meet all of their educational and social needs either way. They both take lots of effort on your part. I've looked into both, my mom has been on the School Board in WA for almost 16 years, my older sister has the home school debate with herself almost daily. I say weigh the pros and cons without emotion attached, pick what you think is best for your kids, pray for help, then give your all to your decision. You can always try home school and switch back to public school if it doesn't work out or if it becomes a better choice later. Don't rely on everyone else's opinion. You are totally capable of making that huge decision, without the guilt of what everyone else thinks (however well-intentioned, they are people who love you after all...), and you will make the right one.
Melanie
I've been a public school teacher and I'm married to a public school teacher, so you know where I stand. Being involved, regular communication with the teacher and supplementing at home when needed - will cut any frustration down quite a bit. The social experience both good & bad is so important.
I would have said public until I married my husband who was home schooled. I still don't know what I will do with my own children, but I DO know that there are LOTS of benefits to homeschooling. And I think that children can get plenty of social interaction as long as parents make the effort to have them around other children - and it can definitely be outside of a public classroom. Let me also just say, that all home schooled children are NOT "weird," and there are PLENTY of "weird" kids that come out of a public school! There's lots more I could say, but I'll end by just saying that I think most people are too closed minded to the idea of home schooling because it takes a TON of effort from the parent. I think kids can benefit from either, and neither should be ruled out without serious contemplation.
Post a Comment